This document describes the third iteration of my attempt at a reasonable implementation of generics for go based on the idea of template packages.

You can compile gotgo by typing

./build

and you can run it on an example template file by typing

./gotgo/gotgo pkg/gotgo/slice.got int string

A complete example is in the example/ subdirectory.

cd example
./build
./example

If you want to see what a template package will look like, check out slice.got, which is a simple package exporting handy functions for slices, such as Map, Fold, Filter, Append, Cat (concat).

A template package is contained in a got file, ending with the .got extension. As you might be able to guess, "got" stands for "go template". If you call gotgo with a --package-name flag, you can generate a go file which is a member of any package you like.

The got file differs from an ordinary go file only in its package line, which will be something like

package slice(type a, type b a)

This defines a package template named "slice", with two type parameters. The first could be any type, which will be called "a", and the second type, called "b" will default to be the same as "a", if no second type parameter is provided. The default type argument is optional, and will itself default to interface{}. The default type should be either an interface type, or a type defined in terms of other template parameters, although I'm not sure whether/how to enforce this. Your got file should be able to compile with the default type!

Within this package, the types "a" and "b" will be in scope, so the slice got file might contain:

func Append(slice []a, datum a) []a {
    // first expand if needed...
    slice = slice[0:len(slice)+1]
    slice[len(slice)-1] = datum
    return slice
}

We could also have a function that uses both "a" and "b":

func Map(f func(a) b, slice []a) []b {
    out := make([]b, len(slice))
    for i,v := range slice {
        out[i] = f(v)
    }
    return out
}

If you want to use the above package, you typically do so by creating an ordinary go file that has a special import statement that specifies the types desired. Currently, this is not automated, as gotgo is in rapid flux.

import intslice "./slice(int)"

func foo(x int, xs []int, ...) {
    ...
    intslice.Append(xs,x)

This import is valid go (since the language spec states that the interpretation of the import string is implementation-dependent), and is accepted by the go compiler, so long as the slice(int) package has been generated and compiled.

The package name of this templated import may be dependent on the gotgo implementation unless you use the --package-name flag when running gotgo.

We can get a bit fancier in the package specification by using interfaces.

package list(type a fmt.Stringer)

import fmt "fmt"

type T struct {
    Datum a
    Next *T
}
func (l T) String() String {
    if l.Next != nil {
        return l.Datum.String() + ", " + l.Next.String()
    } else {
        return l.Datum.String()
    }
}

This isn't much different from what I've already described, but there is (will be) an additional twist that isn't shown, which is that if you make the default type an interface, then any type parameter passed to the template must satisfy that interface! This is valuable because it means that you can guarantee that you can't break the compile of any client code unless you change the template signature.

If you write a template that requires a numeric type, such as

package maxmin(type a int)

func max(x,y a) a {
    if x > y { return x }
    return y
}

then you'll need to use a numeric type as your default. The gotgo system will then enforce that this package may only be parametrized with types that are assignment-compatible3 with int (or whatever default type you choose).

There is a simple program called gotgo, which you pass the filepath to a .got file and a list of types. By default, gotgo outputs the go code to stdout, but if you specify -o foo.go, it will create a file named foo.go.

A zeroconf go build system will need to track down and build imported packages, and in order to work with gotgo, will need to know how to build templated packages. An sketch of a helper for such a build system is provided in the gotimports program, which (non-recursively and incorrectly) dumps some make rules that might be helpful in creating your own Makefile.

• In go, there is no way to write a generic data structure, such as a linked list. As the FAQ points out, this isn't such a problem, since go has a pretty nice stable of built-in data structures, but it is a problem, since sooner or later you'll run into a need for more complicated structures (e.g. perhaps a red-black tree), and you don't want to reimplement them for every data type you use.

• In go, there is no way to write a generic function whose return type depends on its input, or with two arguments of the same (but variable type). This is a much more serious shortcoming than the previous one, as it means you can't even write generic functions for the existing built-in generic data structures. For example, consider the generic version of

  func Append(x int, xs []int) []int
  

  which will append the given value to the slice, expanding it if needed. This is precisely the sort of function you'd like to write only once (or twice perhaps, to treat "large" data types differently), but currently copy-and-paste is the only way to reuse this code. (And similarly for methods...)

• Compile time penalty of templates. In C++, using templates means recompiling the template every time you use it. Using gotgo, however, templates are separately compiled, just like any other go package. So a template need be compiled once by gotgo, and then once for each type it is parametrized by, which is the minimal number of recompiles consistent with allowing the compiler to generate optimal code for each type.

• In the latest gotgo, you can use the --package-name flag to generate a go file in a given package. This makes it possible to use generics with private data types, or in the same package that defines a data type.